Unpious
  • Home
  • Essays
    • Opinion
    • Reflections
    • First Person
    • Reports
    • The Unpious Posek
    • Best of the Blogs
    • Editor's Picks
  • Readings
    • Poetry
    • Fiction
    • Humor
  • Topics
    • Love & Sex
    • Religion
    • Family
    • Off the Derech
    • The Frum World
  • Arts & Culture
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Theatre
  • News & Media
  • Briefly Noted
    • Super-Kosher Sex
    • Comments of the Week
    • How They Got Here
    • From The Archives
  • Blogs
    • FreiFem
  • Contests
    • Winter 2010 Contest
    • Short Essay Contests
    • Winter 2011 Contest
  • About this site
  • Submission Guidelines
  • The Unpious Store
  • Volunteer Info
    • Write for Us
      • Kissing Mendel’s Ass
  • Glossary
  • Subscribe
  • May 24, 2013

Musings on post-religious life, marriage, motherhood, and femininity.

Hatchet to the Heart

The cost of leaving is high. So is the cost of staying.
August 24, 2011
By FreiFem

credit: Gabriela Camerotti

Nazish Noorani was shot in the heart last week, as she pushed her son in a stroller through the streets of Boonton, NJ. Her husband has been arrested and charged with murder.

Lisa Belkin reports that Nazish had left her husband more than once, telling her family he abused her, but she kept on coming back because of her children, and, her cousin suggests, because her Pakistani heritage emphasized the importance of maintaining her marriage at all costs.

It’s a tragic, awful story, and it reminded me, in some way, of the stories of people who stay in the religious community because they are afraid to declare their marriage a failure, or afraid of losing or hurting their children. Clearly, there are differences in these two scenarios, but there are also similarities. The sacrifice made by people who want to leave but choose to stay is not a bullet to the heart – it’s often like a hatchet to the heart, as they frequently must deny their very self, their values and beliefs, living a false and shallow life, day after day, year after year, for the sake of their children or marriage.

This is not to say I cavalierly advocate everybody who wants to leave the religious world, waltzing off. I understand how harsh the cost of that choice can be. But the cost of staying is also harsh. It is also a tragedy, even if its victims are never named in a newspaper.

Printable Version Printable Version

Share |

Tags: Lisa Belkin, murder, Nazish Noorani

Line Break

Author: FreiFem (95 Articles)

One Response to “ Hatchet to the Heart ”

  1. zev on August 28, 2011 at 10:53 pm

    i need some help on that

    Like this comment? Thumb up 1

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

 

Connect


Follow @UnpiousMagazine on Twitter


Latest Articles

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children

    By Shulem Deen

    Judge orders custody switch, citing concerns that the mother’s influence might jeopardize the children’s religious upbringing.

  • Making Families a Priority Making Families a Priority

    By Leah V.

    Battling the ultra-Orthodox community’s efforts to separate OTD parents from their children.

  • A Raizel by Any Other Name A Raizel by Any Other Name

    By Shulem Deen

    “Sean?!” my mother asked. “That’s what you go by now?” Her disdain was obvious, but I needed a moniker that jibed with the ethnically neutral persona I now sought.


MORE IN ESSAYS

From the Archives

  • The Crack in the Western Wall The Crack in the Western Wall

    By Samuel Katz

    Musings on Lamentations.

  • Office Girls Office Girls

    By Chani Mink

    I needed a job, any job. They needed an office girl. Office girls didn’t need to know about volcanoes. There are none in Brooklyn.

  • It’s All Kosher (No. 1): Trapped in New Square It’s All Kosher (No. 1): Trapped in New Square

    By The Unpious Posek

    A young woman who is desperate to leave New Square asks the Unpious Posek for advice.

  • Closed Doors Closed Doors

    By Misyavni

    It’s five-thirty. The last of the other girls and their little handbags have sidled out already. She faces the bathroom door–towards East–as she begins to pray Mincha, swaying gently, a woman’s shuckle.

  • The Expert The Expert

    By Jesse Miller

    A yeshiva bochur, frustrated with his stagnant life, consults with a “specialist,” who narrows down the problem.


MORE IN ESSAYS

FreiFem: The Unpious Double X

  • Mice and Pregnancy and Birth, Oh My! Mice and Pregnancy and Birth, Oh My!

    Aug 19, 2011 / 1 Comment

    Facing prenatal anxiety.

  • Be a River Be a River

    May 11, 2011 / No Comments

    In the first few years after I left the frum community, it felt as if my story defined me so totally I didn’t know how to filter it. Now, I try to avoid mentioning it.

  • “Honey, I’m Gay.” “Honey, I’m Gay.”

    Jun 15, 2011 / 7 Comments

    Can love survive if a marriage doesn’t?


MORE IN FREIFEM

The After Life Podcast

From our friends Sol and Ushi: Lighthearted reflections on life after leaving Hasidic Judaism.

  • #008 Looking Back, Looking Forward
  • #007 The Wicked Ones
  • #006 What Is It About Music? Part II
  • #005 What Is It About Music? Part I
  • #004 The Games We Play
  • #003 Too Shul for School
  • #002 Build It and They Will Stay Out
  • #001 Oh, The Food You'll Eat

Learn more at TheAfterLifePodcast.com.

Doodle Dept.

Oy Vey Cartoons

Another project by the multi-talented Ms. Shtrimpkind. Check it out.

ELSEWHERE ON THE WEB…

The Sound of Sin
By Shulem Deen
.
From Salon.com: How one little Panasonic radio tore apart my marriage -- and my faith.
Life After Hasidism
From The Brooklyn Ink
.
Article on Jacob Gluck of Hasidic Williamsburg Tour and Unpious contributor Yakov Yosef.
The Shomrim: Gotham's Crusaders
From The Village Voice
.
Profile of Brooklyn's Shomrim patrol groups, featuring Luzer Twersky. To read some of Luzer's essays, click here.
Venturing Beyond The Ultra-Orthodox World
From NPR: All Things Considered
.
An interview with Samuel Katz about his journey into the secular world. To read some of Samuel's essays, click here.
It Gets Besser
By Leah Vincent and Samuel Katz
.
Photo montage of lives in transition.

Facebook Recommends…

Most Popular

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children
  • Monsey Underworld
  • Super-Kosher Sex: Natural vs. Unnatural Acts
  • Square One
  • Men in Black
  • First Blush of Sin
  • Between Paris and Williamsburg: “I Am Forbidden,” by Anouk Markovits
  • Making Families a Priority
  • The Frum Pedophile
  • Odd One Out
  • The Weberman Trial, or: The Wolf Who Cried Bias
  • My Hirsute Pursuit
  • The Good Chasidic Wife
  • After the Double Life
  • From Hasid to Headbanger

Most Commented

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children (88)
  • Crossing Marcy (49)
  • Men in Black (45)
  • The Weberman Trial, or: The Wolf Who Cried Bias (34)
  • From Hasid to Headbanger (29)
  • Making Families a Priority (27)
  • Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, Leader of Charedi “Yeshivish” Community, Dies at 102 (25)
  • First Blush of Sin (24)
  • The Frum Pedophile (24)
  • The Dealer (23)

Similar Articles

  • It’s All Kosher (No. 4): The Double Life Dilemma
  • “Honey, I’m Gay.”
  • Marital Experiments
  • From the Archives: The Mask
  • Making Families a Priority
  • Sex-Selective Abortion
  • It’s All Kosher (No. 7): Victim or Survivor?
  • The Train Station
  • To Cut or Not to Cut
  • The Frum Pedophile

Recent Comments

  • Feivish Vincent: thanks for donating and commenting u inspired the author anouk markovicth from “i am...
  • joshie: ken (another yoily i assume) might be the most disgusting creature to ever walk this planet…although, i...
  • daniel: Jeez, i had no idea Jews could be such dicks. I mean I kinda did, but not on this level. This Hasidic...
  • Gracee Moon: I am not Jewish, but it seems to me if the Judge and her ex-husband said she was a good and loving...
  • Chris: The mother needs to focus all of her attention on what child protection legistlation that these people...
  • Chris: The mother needs to focus her attention on all of the people involved in this and look at what child...
  • Brett: The Hasidic community, time and time again, has proven to be full of Hipocracy, lies, deceit, thievery,...
  • Dani kedar: I accept that Satmar are Jews, and I love them as such. However, they are not Hasidim. Hasidus simply...
  • feivish: Please we only have 23 donors while this article has close to a thousned likes?! u cannot just like and...
  • K Behrens: Wow, that is incredibly stupid on the judge’s part. She’s not selfish for wanting something...

Support this Site

We need your help in order to continue to provide quality content. Make your donation now.

Copyright © 2013 Unpious. All Rights Reserved.
Magazine Basic theme designed by Themes by bavotasan.com.
Powered by WordPress.