Unpious
  • Home
  • Essays
    • Opinion
    • Reflections
    • First Person
    • Reports
    • The Unpious Posek
    • Best of the Blogs
    • Editor's Picks
  • Readings
    • Poetry
    • Fiction
    • Humor
  • Topics
    • Love & Sex
    • Religion
    • Family
    • Off the Derech
    • The Frum World
  • Arts & Culture
    • Books
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Theatre
  • News & Media
  • Briefly Noted
    • Super-Kosher Sex
    • Comments of the Week
    • How They Got Here
    • From The Archives
  • Blogs
    • FreiFem
  • Contests
    • Winter 2010 Contest
    • Short Essay Contests
    • Winter 2011 Contest
  • About this site
  • Submission Guidelines
  • The Unpious Store
  • Volunteer Info
    • Write for Us
      • Kissing Mendel’s Ass
  • Glossary
  • Subscribe
  • May 21, 2013

Memoir

Heat of the Moment

A small act of mindless cruelty leads to reflection, kindness, and redemption.
March 1, 2012
By Shtreimel

Credit: Flickr / Unhindered by Talent

“Chicago is here,” Moishy said.

Chicago was an American living in Jerusalem who had fallen on hard times, or, possibly, had always lived hard. He may have had family somewhere in another part of Jerusalem or somewhere not far, or not at all. Details of his life, such as where he was from and how he got here, were mysterious, but the one thing he couldn’t hide was his thick American accent. Hence the nickname: “Chicago.”

Now he was here again, on one of his twice-weekly rounds, going from table to table, jiggling the coins in his hand. For some reason or other I had taken to disliking Chicago. He was cheerful, usually, never insisted that you give him something, the way most beggars did, and he never cursed when you shrugged your shoulders to indicate, “Sorry, don’t have.” But there was something about him that irritated me, his round belly, his accent, scruffy beard, the way he looked away when I made eye contact, or maybe it was his aversion to small talk. To this day I can’t figure it out.

“I can make sure he never comes around again,” I said to the bucherim at my table.

They all turned to me, curious. Beri, at the corner, continued shokelling so the mashgiach wouldn’t notice that he’s chatting instead of studying – his every move calculated for its effect on his eventual shidduch (although, quite strangely, if I’m not mistaken, he ended up getting divorced).
I collected a pile of coins from my table-mates. The boys looked on from the corners of their eyes lest the mashgiach on duty notice the commotion. I piled the coins up neatly, borrowed a cigarette lighter from one of the more eager faces around me and heated up the stack. Chicago was only a few steps away, inching slowly towards us. There were too many eyes on me – a point of no return if ever there was one. I knew I was doing something terrible before he reached for the neat and very hot stack. I was overcome with guilt even before I heard him scream.
The whole shul heard him scream.

“I don’t know, I just don’t know,” I told the menahel. I really didn’t know why I did it. I couldn’t explain it to myself, let alone to someone else.

“I have to kick you out,” the menahel said. For once I agreed . I deserved to be suspended. But I wasn’t. He must have sensed my guilt and in his infinite wickedness he probably wanted it to simmer and stew inside of me.

Chicago never came by again. I often saw him sitting in the coffee room of a neighborhood shul that had minyanim until late morning. I started avoiding that shul, which back then meant waking up early to catch the yeshiva minyan. On days that I awoke too late and had no choice but to attend that shul, I tried entering through the back , or I hurried through the main doors, eyes downcast, hoping to pass unnoticed. Lucky for me, Chicago never looked up from what he was doing. He always sat facing the crowd, his eyes on the floor or on people’s shoes, his hands at the ready for spare change.

Word of my callous act didn’t reach far, it appears, for within a year I was engaged to a wonderful girl. I knew, however, that I couldn’t get married before I asked Chicago for forgiveness. I did not want to have shalom bayis problems, deformed kids, a life of poverty, to become inflicted with a nasty illness, or a host of other things I begged God daily that he spare me. Chicago was still there in the coffee room. I walked in there one day, tried to make eye contact but he wouldn’t meet my gaze. I gave the man a 20-dollar bill. He looked up for a moment to see if I wanted change. I just smiled and said, “It’s for you.” “Thank you,” he said. If he recognized me he hid it very well. But I still hadn’t asked for forgiveness, I just didn’t know how to.

Purim came around, and I decided to collect whatever I could and give it to Chicago. I ended up with over 1,000 shekel, which I gave him in a little plastic bag. Chicago opened it, looked at it, looked at me, smiled, then looked down and thanked me, or the floor. I was leaving Israel in a few weeks, and getting married soon after. I was desperate and out of ideas.

My last Shabbos in Israel, I woke up terribly late. I went to daven at the local minyan factory, then went to another shul where bucherim knew to go after late prayers, where they served extra-spicy chulent and Yerushalmi kugel, even for latecomers. But I was late for that too. The shul was empty save for one man: Chicago. He was holding a couple of disposable aluminum pans filled with cholent and dried out pieces of chicken. He was happy to see me. I was happy too.

“Rabbi Chicago” I said, not knowing how else to address him, “I’m so glad to see you here.”

“I have to bring it home, my family is waiting for the food,” he said. He didn’t seem bothered or curious that I’d called him “Rabbi Chicago.” Maybe that was indeed his name.

“I’ll help you carry them,” I offered.

“It’s far,” he said. “And hot”. The address he gave me was far, and the weather was kind of hot for an Israeli day in spring.

Half an hour later I was still walking, panting, and schlepping both pans. Chicago didn’t utter a word the whole time. We walked slowly, mostly uphill as fate would have it. The pans that hadn’t seemed so hot at the beginning were now scalding my palms and the edges of my fingers. I shuffled the weight from arm to arm, trying to disperse the heat evenly, when I suddenly realized that I was being dealt a punishment so apt, so perfect that I could only embrace the pain.

I walked up the three floors to his apartment and laid the pans on the floor outside his doorway, exactly as he instructed. I didn’t get to see his family, but I got to see his eyes when he thanked me.

By the time I walked to my chuppah I no longer had burn marks or blisters, but I knew I had been redeemed.

Printable Version Printable Version

Share |

Tags: cruelty, featured, kindness, tzedakah, yeshiva

Line Break

Author: Shtreimel (8 Articles)

Shtreimel (36) was born in Europe, grew up in the Middle East and now resides in Brooklyn, NY, with his wonderful wife and 6 kids. He graduated in 1994 with degrees in Ms Kidushin, Chulin, and the Three Bavot from the prestigious Mir Yeshiva in Jerusalem, Israel. He also has a knack for subterfuge, white lies, damned lies and outright lying. Most of his writing should not be taken at face value due to the circumstances. Not even this Bio. Some of his untruths may be found at http://hassid.blogspot.com

7 Responses to “ Heat of the Moment ”

  1. confused on March 2, 2012 at 12:32 am

    this was great.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 3

  2. Gabriella on March 3, 2012 at 7:09 pm

    I love this piece on many levels. It leaves pondering about our motivations, about what “help” is, and the title still has me guessing. I hope the heat of the budding romance far outweighted the heat of the guilt, or the coins.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 3

  3. Baal Habos on March 5, 2012 at 7:42 am

    Nice tale. And I luv the bio.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 2

  4. Melanie on March 9, 2012 at 3:24 pm

    I love this, but I still wish he had actually owned up and apologized, even if the “punishment” was so apropos. Engaging and well written, though.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 2

  5. siyum hashas on March 12, 2012 at 2:17 am

    wonderful story, beautifully written, though my humble opinion is that it belonges to be on aish rather then on unpious.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 3

  6. pinny_meisner on March 25, 2012 at 11:41 am

    It’s a nice story but aside from assuaging your conscience you haven’t been redeemed in the least bit. He knows you helped him with the cholent but he has no idea it was you who burnt him with the coins.

    Go back and apologize lest your soul be marked forever.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 1

  7. Oop on October 14, 2012 at 1:38 pm

    My first reaction was, hey! What is this article doing here? But then on second thought, it does provide a glimpse into the psyche of the average yeshivas bachur, or avriech. And it’s beautifully written.

    Like this comment? Thumb up 3

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

 

Connect


Follow @UnpiousMagazine on Twitter


Latest Articles

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children

    By Shulem Deen

    Judge orders custody switch, citing concerns that the mother’s influence might jeopardize the children’s religious upbringing.

  • Making Families a Priority Making Families a Priority

    By Leah V.

    Battling the ultra-Orthodox community’s efforts to separate OTD parents from their children.

  • A Raizel by Any Other Name A Raizel by Any Other Name

    By Shulem Deen

    “Sean?!” my mother asked. “That’s what you go by now?” Her disdain was obvious, but I needed a moniker that jibed with the ethnically neutral persona I now sought.


MORE IN ESSAYS

From the Archives

  • Red Nail Polish Red Nail Polish

    By Tova Schwartz

    Anger registers on the shver’s face. He tells me to pull, pull my sleeves down! But no amount of tugging will make my sleeves longer, and he looks disgusted with me.

  • No Return No Return

    By Shulem Deen

    “Oh, fuck this,” I said. “Let’s go sin then.” He grinned. “Just do it a couple times, it’ll feel natural. Like they say, ‘Transgress, repeat, yada, yada.’”

  • Closed Doors Closed Doors

    By Misyavni

    It’s five-thirty. The last of the other girls and their little handbags have sidled out already. She faces the bathroom door–towards East–as she begins to pray Mincha, swaying gently, a woman’s shuckle.

  • Maimonides and Method Acting Maimonides and Method Acting

    By Samuel Katz

    Maimonides, the the über-rationalist, was supposed to be one of “our guys.” But this time he disappointed me.

  • In Defense of Chasidic Culture In Defense of Chasidic Culture

    By Baal Devarim

    I have decided, following Chazal’s dictum, to be the man where no one else will. I will describe the beauty of the Chasidic lifestyle.


MORE IN ESSAYS

FreiFem: The Unpious Double X

  • Who Are Your Heroes?

    Mar 10, 2011 / 4 Comments

    Tuesday was International Women’s Day, and a time to reflect: Who are the historical or mythical female heroes in our “frei” movement?

  • Waiting With Osniel Waiting With Osniel

    Jul 20, 2011 / No Comments

    A sleepless night.

  • PEX Postcard PEX Postcard

    Jul 4, 2011 / 3 Comments

    Impressions of the PEX Festival.


MORE IN FREIFEM

The After Life Podcast

From our friends Sol and Ushi: Lighthearted reflections on life after leaving Hasidic Judaism.

  • #008 Looking Back, Looking Forward
  • #007 The Wicked Ones
  • #006 What Is It About Music? Part II
  • #005 What Is It About Music? Part I
  • #004 The Games We Play
  • #003 Too Shul for School
  • #002 Build It and They Will Stay Out
  • #001 Oh, The Food You'll Eat

Learn more at TheAfterLifePodcast.com.

Doodle Dept.

Oy Vey Cartoons

Another project by the multi-talented Ms. Shtrimpkind. Check it out.

ELSEWHERE ON THE WEB…

The Sound of Sin
By Shulem Deen
.
From Salon.com: How one little Panasonic radio tore apart my marriage -- and my faith.
Life After Hasidism
From The Brooklyn Ink
.
Article on Jacob Gluck of Hasidic Williamsburg Tour and Unpious contributor Yakov Yosef.
The Shomrim: Gotham's Crusaders
From The Village Voice
.
Profile of Brooklyn's Shomrim patrol groups, featuring Luzer Twersky. To read some of Luzer's essays, click here.
Venturing Beyond The Ultra-Orthodox World
From NPR: All Things Considered
.
An interview with Samuel Katz about his journey into the secular world. To read some of Samuel's essays, click here.
It Gets Besser
By Leah Vincent and Samuel Katz
.
Photo montage of lives in transition.

Facebook Recommends…

Most Popular

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children
  • Monsey Underworld
  • Super-Kosher Sex: Natural vs. Unnatural Acts
  • Square One
  • Men in Black
  • First Blush of Sin
  • Between Paris and Williamsburg: “I Am Forbidden,” by Anouk Markovits
  • Making Families a Priority
  • The Frum Pedophile
  • Odd One Out
  • The Weberman Trial, or: The Wolf Who Cried Bias
  • My Hirsute Pursuit
  • The Good Chasidic Wife
  • From Hasid to Headbanger
  • After the Double Life

Most Commented

  • Ex-Hasidic Mother Loses Custody of Children (70)
  • Crossing Marcy (49)
  • Men in Black (45)
  • Overheard at the Asifa Protest: Quotes, Moments, & Vignettes (42)
  • The Weberman Trial, or: The Wolf Who Cried Bias (34)
  • From Hasid to Headbanger (29)
  • Making Families a Priority (27)
  • Rabbi Yosef Shalom Elyashiv, Leader of Charedi “Yeshivish” Community, Dies at 102 (25)
  • First Blush of Sin (24)
  • The Frum Pedophile (24)

Similar Articles

  • Bottlecap Baseball
  • A Gitten Chodesh
  • Sex Ed
  • Yeshiva Nights
  • Union Square Park
  • A Walk in the Park
  • Pans in Rage
  • The Chametz Warrior
  • Blessings in Disguise
  • Vill’amsburg Diaries: Morning Sins

Recent Comments

  • yocheved: I really don’t think this case should become about ALL Hasidim in Rockland county! The family court...
  • Yocheved: This is not about religion but about the safety of these children. If the mother feels they are being...
  • Dannielle (Dossy) Blumenthal: This whole spectacle is so sad. Jew vs. Jew. Post the public information so that we can...
  • Barbara: Ken you scumbag she DOES work in the city ( full time job) for starters. Second even if she DOES open her...
  • Barbara: I know a lot about this case, and in true form the chassidim are out in the mass and twisting their lies as...
  • ken: When will responsible Moms and Dads realize to put their own differences aside and learn to put their kids...
  • Sara: By the way to the comment maker that said that the court would not say that they are removing the kids because...
  • oNE kiNgs lAnE cOuPon CodE: As soon as I discovered this site I went on reddit to share some of the love with them.
  • S r: Clearly, neither parent is healthy. kids will need major therapy.
  • Donna: David: I would not say that someone is a fool if they form an opinion re this case without hearing the...

Support this Site

We need your help in order to continue to provide quality content. Make your donation now.

Copyright © 2013 Unpious. All Rights Reserved.
Magazine Basic theme designed by Themes by bavotasan.com.
Powered by WordPress.